It’s essentially a novel that traffics in pastiche (plagiarism?) and is built on two startling plot twists (and as such tailor made for the screen). It’s not like Waters is serving up any profound insights into human nature or casting her eye over a wide panorama of human life. This novel, for me all pastiche, pasteboard and mirrors, really irritated me principally because I could have read two good novels in the time it took me to wade through it.įor a start it’s way too long. Not that there's anything wrong with 'middlebrow', especially coming from a lady like this who proved that she had no idea what a 17-year-old reluctant reader would be pleased to get as a gift and instead was imposing her own values on this poor girl.(shame, shame) hey, kid - hope you enjoy the journals of john evelyn!! a real page-turner!Īll i know is this is a truly enjoyable and memorable book,and my brows suit me perfectly. middlebrow.' (david, i am using your voice here to recreate, i hope you don't mind) 'i don't want to sound fatuous, but i suppose i shall say it anyway. Seriously - this book is a genuine crowd pleaser, even though the obnoxious lady from last week dismissed it. in this case, there is a young woman raised by a band of thieves (a band of thieves!!!) who gets roped into perpetrating a pretty long con only to find herself in a love triangle and perhaps being conned herself. and this is her at her very best.įor me, the best aspect of the victorian is the marginalized, the liminal members of society and what they do to get by. and then i felt that gutsick christmas midafternoon void where you look around and whimper hopefully - 'more?'. Sarah waters is an author i always break my 'save one book' vow with - her last two books, i had to buy the very day they came in, i slapped a 'do not disturb' sign on my head and i just plowed through them in a matter of hours. but be honest, i had you at lesbian dickens.

it is almost 600 pages of puppy-shuddering bliss. not a detective-y whodunnit mystery, but more traditionally dickens/collins family mystery with elements of mamet's house of games. there is also a kickass 'mystery' plot in here.

sarah waters has some amazing strengths - she creates well-developed, complicated characters, she is a master at pacing, she can construct very tight, multi-layered narratives where the next move is always surprising, and she recreates the victorian setting better than anyone else that i have read. So, now that i have a little breathing room, i will do my best. dana has been bugging me to write a review of this for the longest time, and now that she is on vacation and out of my path for ten minutes (seriously - the girl moved to my town just so she could stand under my window all night calling 'hey!! heyyy!! write a review for fingersmith! come on, you know you want to!!')

Vingervlug by Sarah Waters